The Lilywhites met Cinderford Town for the only time in the Club's history in 2004.The Gloucestershire Club, who play at the Causeway Ground, had been founded in 1922.
6.11.2004 Cinderford Town 1 - 1 Cambridge City 1st Round Cambridge City team: Duncan Roberts, Craig Pope, Lee Chaffey, Glen Fuff, Matt Langstan, Richard Scott, Rob Miller, Alex Fiddes, Robbie Simpson, Carl Williams and Dale Binns. Subs used were Pell for Williams and Michael Gash for Miller. Robbie Simpson scored for the Lilywhites.
9.11.2004 Cambridge City 3 - 1 Cinderford Town 1st Round Replay Cambridge City team: Roberts, Pope, Lee Summerscales, Fuff, Langstan, Scott, Fiddes, Williams, Robbie Simpson, Gash and Binns. Subs used were Miller for Fiddes and Daniel Talbot for Binns. Scorers for the Lilywhites were Miller, Gash and Williams.