The only meetings between the Lilywhites and Matlock Town have been in cup matches.
7.11.1989 Matlock Town 2 - 1 Cambridge City Cambridge City team: Kevin Murray, Simon Haigh, Laurence Cullum, Steve Fallon, Phil Hubbard, Steve Gawthrop, Steve Low, Graham Daniels, Garg Grogan, Kevin Wilkin and Keith Lockhart. Sub used was Ian Goddard. The Lilywhites goal was a penalty from Keith Lockart.
27.11.1990 Matlock Town 2 - 1 Cambridge City Cambridge City team: Kevin Murray, Simon Haigh, Andy Beattie, Steve Fallon, Laurence Cullum, Paul Wilkin, Domenico Genovese, Peter Lindsay, Keith Lockhart, John McLean and Gary Grogan. Sub used was Andy Morton. The goal scorer for the Lilywhites was Domenico Genovese.
14.9.2006 Cambridge 0 - 0 Matlock Town Cambridge City team: Danny Naisbitt, Craig Pope, Lee Chaffey, Darren Coe, Glenn Fuff, Ben Bowditch, Stuart Sinclair, Greg Lincoln, Darren Lynch, Neil Midgley and Craig Radcliffe. Subs used were Lee Roach and Lewis Baillie.
17.10.2006 Matlock Town 2 - 3 Cambridge City (after extra time0 Cambridge City team: Naisbitt, Pope, Chaffey, Coe, Fuff, Bowditch, Sinclair, Lincoln, Midgley and Radcliffe. Subs used were Kalam Mooniaruck, Sam Reed and Lewis Baillie. Matlock missed two penalties.
31.10.2009 Cambridge City 0 - 1 Matlock Town Cambridge City team: Zac Barrett, Matt Haniver, James Krause, Laurie Stewart, Lee Chaffey, Robbie Nightingale, Tom Burke, Adie Cambridge, Steve Gentle, John Frendo and Ashley Fuller. Subs used were Neil Midgley for Fuller, Dave Theobald for Gentle and Tom Pepper for Haniver.