The Lilywhites first played Bognor Regis Town FC in September 2004. They had been founded in 1883 and have always played at Nyewood Lane in Bognor Regis.
Conference South (NL 2)
25.9.2004 Bognor Regis Town 1 - 2 Cambridge City Cambridge City team: Catton, Pope, Chaffey, Fuff. Langstan, Scott, Miller, Williams, Sadler, Robbie Simpson and Binns. Sub used was Stevenson for Robbie Simpson. Scorers for the Lilywhites were Sadler and Stevenson.
22.1.2005 Cambridge City 1 - 0 Bognor Regis Town Cambridge City team: Roberts, Pope, Chaffey, Stone, Langstan, Fiddes, Williams, Josh Simpson, Robinson, Robbie Simpson and Binns. Sub used was Scott for Binns. The scorer for the Lilywhites was Scott.
17.9.2005 Bognor Regis Town 4 - 2 Cambridge City Cambridge City team: Millard, Pope, Chaffey, Fuff, Langston, Southon, Williams, Molesley, Robbie Simpson, Booth and Josh Simpson. Subs used were Dobson for Josh Simpson and Parmenter for Southon. Scorers for the Lilywhites were Robbie Simpson and Booth from the penalty spot. Josh Simpson was making his debut for the Lilywhites.
4.3.2006 Cambridge City 2 - 0 Bognor Regis Town Cambridge City team: Naisbitt, Pope, Blanchett, Fuff, Langstan, Josh Simpson, Dobson, Lincoln, Gash, Booth and Binns. Subs used were Robbie Simpson for Gash. Stone for Booth and Jarrett for Dobson. Both of the goals for the Lilywhites were scored by Booth.
9.9.2006 Bognor Regis Town 0 - 1 Cambridge City Cambridge City team: Naisbitt, Pope, Blanchett, Chaffey, Fuff, Bowditch, Sinclair, Lincoln, Lynch, Roache and Radcliffe. Subs used were Reed for Roache and Mackie for Lynch. The goalscorer for the Lillywhites was Roache.
17.4.2007 Cambridge City 2 - 0 Bognor Regis Town Cambridge City team: Naisbitt, Pope, Radcliffe, Chaffey, Fuff, Lincoln, E'Beyer, Midgley, Gash, Roache and Henry. Subs used were Baillie for Lincoln, Bowditch for E'Beyer and Sinclair for Roache. The goalscorers for the Lilywhites were Gash and Roache.
27.10.2007 Bognor Regis Town 2 - 0 Cambridge City Cambridge City team: Herbert, Bruce, Theobald, Chaffey, Wall, Bowditch, Roache, Simpson, Gash, Thomas and Fuller. Subs used were Midgley for Radcliffe, Wales for Roache and Chick for Wall. Both Anthony Thomas and Chick ere making their first appearances for the Lilywhites.
15.3.2008 Cambridge City 2 - 2 Bognor Regis Town Cambridge City team: Timms, Bruce, Radcliffe, Chaffey, Theobald, Stephen Smith, Hanvier, Josh Simpson, Roberts, Roache and Fuller. Subs used were Midgley for Brunce and E'Beyer for Smith. Roberts scored one of the goals for the Lilywhites from the penalty spot, while the other was an own goal by the Bognor Regis number 3, Sam Wallis-Tayler.