The first match between the Lilywhites and Haverhill Rovers was a friendly match at the start of the 1909/10 season. The same season the two clubs played each other in the East Anglian League and the Suffolk Senior Club. Founded in 1886, Haverhill Rovers originally played at Seven Acres before in 1913 they moved to Hamlet Cross. This proved to be their home for nearly 100 years, as in 2010 they moved to the New Croft Community Stadium in Chalkstone Way, Haverhill.
East Anglian League
16.10.1909 Cambridge Town 2 - 1 Haverhill Rovers Played at Purbeck Road, the Lilywhites' goals were scored by Ellis and Halls.
19.2.1910 Haverhill Rovers 1 - 2 Cambridge Town Played at Seven Acres, the goals for the Lilywhites were scored by Doig and Coe.
Bury and District League
3.12.1910 Cambridge Town 4 - 0 Haverhill Rovers Scorers for the Lilywhites were Flack, Stokes and Naylor (2)
22..4.1911 Haverhill Rovers 1 - 1 Cambridge Town Coe scored for the Lilywhites.
11.11.1911 Cambridge Town 2 - 1 Haverhill Rovers First match between the two sides at the Hills Road Bridge Ground. Scorers for the Lilywhites were Flack and Doig.
13.1.1912 Haverhill Rovers 8 - 2 Cambridge Town Colville and Brookes scored for the Lilywhites.
15.11.1919 Cambridge Town 1 - 1 Haverhill Rovers Played at Magdalene College, this was the first match between the two sides since 1912. Vic Watson scored for the Lilywhites.
20.12.1919 Haverhill Rovers 1 - 1 Cambridge Town This was the first match the Lilywhites played at the Hamlet Cross Ground in Haverhill, with Manning scoring the Lilywhites goal.
Amateur Football Alliance Senior Cup
22.10.1910 Cambridge Town 3 - 2 Haverhill Rovers 2nd Qualifying Round Richardson and Sizer (2) scored for the Lilywhites.
East Anglian Cup
19.12.1988 Cambridge City 1 - 1 Haverhill Rovers (after extra time) 2nd Round First time the two teams had met for nearly 70 years and Haverhill's first visit to Milton Road. Kevin Wilkin scored for the Lilywhites.
24.1.1988 Haverhill Rovers 1 - 3 Cambridge City 2nd Round Replay Two goals by Gary Grogan and an own goal booked the Lilywhites place in the next round.
29.3.1990 Haverhill Rovers 0 - 6 Cambridge City Area Final Goals scored for the Lilywhites were by Kevin Wilkin (3 including a penalty), Paul Wilkin, Steve Gawthrop and Keith Lockhart (penalty).
Suffolk Senior Cup
5.2.1910 Haverhill Rovers 1 - 5 Cambridge Town 1st Round Scorers for the Lilywhites were Richardson (penalty), Coe, Halls and Stokes (2)
18.2.1911 Cambridge Town 1 - 1 Haverhill Rovers 2nd Round Naylor scored for the Lilywhites.
25.2.1911 Haverhill Rovers 3 - 1 Cambridge Town 2nd Round Replay Jenkins was the scorer for the Lilywhites.
11.9.1909 Cambridge Town 3 - 2 Haverhill Rovers Goals for the Lilywhites scored by Coe (2) and Halls.