The Lilywhites first played Barwell, who were founded in 1992 following the merger of Barwell Athletic and Hinckley F.C., on December 29th, 2011
Southern Premier (NL 3)
29.12.2011 Cambridge City 3 - 0 Barwell Cambridge City team: Zac Barrett, Jamie McGowan, Ahmed Deen, Dave Theobald, Lee Chaffey, Adie Cambridge, Craig Bussens, Jamie Gould, Craig Hammond, Danny Kelly and Joey Abbs. Subs used were Neil Midgley for Cambridge, Lowden for Deen and Lee Clift for Kelly. Scorers for the Lilywhites were Theobald and Clift.
17.3.2011 Barwell 0 - 2 Cambridge City Cambridge City team: Barrett, Ben Islam, Pat Bexfield, Theobald, Victor Torres, Cambridge, Clift, David Prada, Hammond, Mitchell Bryant and Ben Bradbury. Subs used were Midgley for Bradbury and Robbie Nightingale for Cambridge. Both goals for were scored by Hammond.
4.9.2012 Cambridge City 2 - 1 Barwell Cambridge City team: Enol Ordonez, Bexfield, James Brighton, Theobald, Chaffey, Nightingale, Luke Allen, Cambridge, Hammond, Bryant and Christain Lester. Sub used was Prada for Cambridge. Goalscorers for the Lilywhites were Hammond and Bryant.
12.1.2013 Barwell 1 - 0 Cambridge City Cambridge City team: Barrett, Jack Dekanski, Charlie Death, Theobald, Chaffey, Nightingale, Cambridge, Allen, Bryant, Adam Marriott and Ashley Fuller. Subs used were Prada and Midgley. Jack Debanski was playing his last game for the Lilywhites.